Frequently Asked Questions

Where do you ship?

We ship all across the United States. Currently, we are not able to ship outside of the U.S. due to safety, quality, and customs concerns.

Can I pick a specific date for the delivery of the order?

Unfortunately we cannot guarantee a specific delivery date for your order. Because it does take time to process and pack your order, and because Scafuri Bakery relies on other companies to deliver our cookies (USPS and Federal Express), it is challenging to guarantee specific days & times. However, if this is a pressing matter, and your request coincides with our current operating hours, you can email us at and we can attempt to process your request using overnight delivery. Please understand this is not always an option, and during COVID-19 operations, delays can occur with the bakery and the postal service.

Can I include a note with my order if I am sending something as a gift?

Of course! During checkout you can type in the "add a note" field and we will include a note in the box on a beautiful Scafuri postcard.

Can I place an order and pick it up in the shop?

Currently, we do not offer in-store pickup using the online order form. Feel free to stop by our Taylor Street location or email us at to arrange in-store pickup. Sometimes a minimum quantity is required. Typically a minimum 72 notice is required.

How many Italian cookies are in a pound?

The weight varies between cookies, so we have specified on each cookie's page how many typically make a pound. For assortments, you may get anywhere from 14-24 cookies in a pound. The numbers are just an estimate and may not be exact due to differing weights and sizes of the handmade cookies.